1895 : 1-2-0

Coach: No Coach

PA	PF	W/L	Date	Opponent	Location	Notes
6	0	W	09-28-1895	Chicago YMCA (IL)	Lake Forest, IL
0	52	L	10-05-1895	Chicago (IL)	Chicago, IL
0	14	L	10-09-1895	Armour Institute (IL)	Chicago, IL

1896 : 3-4-1

Coach: No Coach

PA	PF	W/L	Date	Opponent	Location	Notes
14	0	W	09-26-1896	Evanston HS (IL)	Lake Forest, IL
0	38	L	10-03-1896	Illinois	Champaign, IL
6	0	W	10-07-1896	North Western Academy (IL)	Lake Forest, IL
0	34	L	10-10-1896	Wisconsin	Madison, WI
0	66	L	10-17-1896	Michigan	Ann Arbor, MI
56	0	W	10-30-1896	Bennett Medical (IL)	Lake Forest, IL
0	0	T	11-10-1896	Chicago (IL)	Chicago, IL
0	12	L	11-13-1896	Ripon (WI)	Ripon, WI

1897 : 4-5-1

Coach: No Coach

PA	PF	W/L	Date	Opponent	Location	Notes
22	0	W	09-25-1897	Evanston HS (IL)	Lake Forest, IL
8	16	L	09-29-1897	Fort Sheridan (IL)	Lake Forest, IL
0	30	L	10-02-1897	Wisconsin	Madison, WI
0	71	L	10-09-1897	Chicago (IL)	Chicago, IL
0	36	L	10-16-1897	Illinois	Champaign, IL
0	0	T	10-23-1897	Hahnemann Medical College (IL)	Lake Forest, IL
18	6	W	10-30-1897	Armour Institute (IL)	Chicago, IL
10	6	W	11-06-1897	Milwaukee Medical College (WI)	Lake Forest, IL
0	42	L	11-13-1897	Beloit (WI)	Beloit, WI
4	0	W	11-20-1897	Northwestern Academy (IL)	Lake Forest, IL

1898 : 2-1-0

Coach: No Coach

PA	PF	W/L	Date	Opponent	Location	Notes
5	0	W	10-26-1898	Waukegan HS (IL)	Lake Forest, IL
0	27	L	10-29-1898	Northwestern (IL)	Evanston, IL
6	0	W	11-05-1898	Lake Forest Academy (IL)	Lake Forest, IL

1899 : 4-6-2

Coach: D.H. Jackson

PA	PF	W/L	Date	Opponent	Location	Notes
11	5	W	09-23-1899	Chicago Lake View HS (IL)	Lake Forest, IL
0	45	L	09-30-1899	Wisconsin	Madison, WI
0	0	T	10-07-1899	Lake Forest Alumni (IL)	Lake Forest, IL
0	38	L	10-14-1899	Notre Dame (IN)	South Bend, IN
11	5	W	10-21-1899	Chicago South Side Academy (IL)	Lake Forest, IL
0	16	L	10-25-1899	Northwestern (IL)	Evanston, IL
17	0	W	11-01-1899	Waukegan HS (IL)	Lake Forest, IL
0	28	L	11-04-1899	Beloit (WI)	Beloit, WI
6	21	L	11-11-1899	Kalamazoo (MI)	Kalamazoo, MI
0	38	L	11-18-1899	Rush Medical (IL)	Chicago, IL
0	0	T	11-25-1899	Bennett Medical (IL)	Lake Forest, IL
21	6	W	11-30-1899	Pontiac AC (IL)	Pontiac, IL