1905 : 1-1-0

Coach: Jack L. Thompson

PA	PF	W/L	Date	Opponent	Location	Notes
10	0	W	1905	Columbus HS (IN)	?
0	6	L	1905	Louisville Manual HS (KY)	?

1906 : 5-1-0

Coach: Jack L. Thompson

PA	PF	W/L	Date	Opponent	Location	Notes
20	0	W	1906	Salem HS (IN)	?
0	6	L	1906	Columbus HS (IN)	?
18	0	W	1906	Madison Commercial Club (IN)	?
60	6	W	1906	Franklin (IN)	?
16	0	W	1906	Lawrenceburg HS (IN)	?
28	0	W	1906	Madison HS (IN)	?

1907 : 3-2-1

Coach: Jack L. Thompson

PA	PF	W/L	Date	Opponent	Location	Notes
0	11	L	10-05-1907	Centre (KY)	Danville, KY
22	0	W	1907	Butler (IN)	?
0	40	L	10-21-1907	Kentucky	Lexington, KY
44	0	W	1907	North Vernon HS (IN)	?
39	0	W	1907	Lawrenceburg HS (IN)	?
6	6	T	1907	Louisville University School (KY)	?

1908 : 4-4-2

Coach: Jack L. Thompson

PA	PF	W/L	Date	Opponent	Location	Notes
0	0	T	1908	Louisville Negro Manual HS (KY)	?
5	5	T	1908	Franklin (IN)	?
17	6	W	1908	Franklin (IN)	?
11	24	L	10-03-1908	Centre (KY)	Danville, KY
79	0	W	1908	North Vernon HS (IN)	?
0	18	L	10-17-1908	Butler (IN)	Indianapolis, IN
9	5	W	10-24-1908	Cincinnati (OH)	?
6	0	W	11-07-1908	Winona Tech (IN)	Hanover, IN
4	10	L	11-14-1908	Saint Mary's (KY)	Hanover, IN
0	10	L	11-21-1908	Butler (IN)	Hanover, IN

1909 : 1-4-0

Coach: E.L. Weber

PA	PF	W/L	Date	Opponent	Location	Notes
2	6	L	10-02-1909	Cincinnati (OH)	Madison, IN
5	23	L	10-16-1909	Butler (IN)	Indianapolis, IN
0	48	L	1909	Wabash (IN)	?
31	5	W	11-06-1909	Franklin (IN)	Hanover, IN
0	6	L	1909	Saint Mary's (KY)	?