1975 : 5-5-0

Coach: Thomas A. "Tommy" Mont

PA	PF	W/L	Date	Opponent	Location	Notes
28	8	W	09-13-1975	Wooster (OH)	Greencastle, IN
32	14	W	09-20-1975	Ohio Wesleyan	Delaware, OH
17	38	L	09-27-1975	Valparaiso (IN)	Greencastle, IN
21	47	L	10-04-1975	Evansville (IN)	Evansville, IN
41	0	W	10-11-1975	Principia (IL)	Greencastle, IN
0	27	L	10-18-1975	Indianapolis (IN)	Indianapolis, IN
12	7	W	10-25-1975	Saint Joseph's (IN)	Greencastle, IN
7	14	L	11-01-1975	Butler (IN)	Indianapolis, IN
22	48	L	11-08-1975	Hope (MI)	Holland, MI
14	8	W	11-15-1975	Wabash (IN)	Greencastle, IN

1976 : 2-8-0

Coach: Thomas A. "Tommy" Mont

PA	PF	W/L	Date	Opponent	Location	Notes
28	22	W	09-11-1976	Hope (MI)	Greencastle, IN
20	23	L	09-18-1976	Ohio Wesleyan	Greencastle, IN
6	21	L	09-25-1976	Rose-Hulman Tech (IN)	Terre Haute, IN
48	7	W	10-02-1976	Eureka (IL)	Greencastle, IN
7	36	L	10-09-1976	Evansville (IN)	Greencastle, IN
7	14	L	10-16-1976	Valparaiso (IN)	Valparaiso, IN
12	14	L	10-23-1976	Indianapolis (IN)	Greencastle, IN
7	23	L	10-30-1976	Butler (IN)	Greencastle, IN
2	24	L	11-06-1976	Saint Joseph's (IN)	Rensselaer, IN
7	14	L	11-13-1976	Wabash (IN)	Crawfordsville, IN

1977 : 1-9-0

Coach: Bob Bergman

PA	PF	W/L	Date	Opponent	Location	Notes
7	55	L	09-10-1977	Hope (MI)	Holland, MI
0	31	L	09-17-1977	Wooster (OH)	Wooster, OH
7	21	L	09-24-1977	Albion (MI)	Greencastle, IN
24	13	W	10-01-1977	Rose-Hulman Tech (IN)	Greencastle, IN
0	10	L	10-08-1977	Evansville (IN)	Evansville, IN
13	38	L	10-15-1977	Valparaiso (IN)	Greencastle, IN
3	31	L	10-22-1977	Indianapolis (IN)	Indianapolis, IN
6	24	L	10-29-1977	Saint Joseph's (IN)	Greencastle, IN
0	41	L	11-05-1977	Butler (IN)	Indianapolis, IN
6	30	L	11-12-1977	Wabash (IN)	Greencastle, IN

1978 : 2-7-0

Coach: Bob Bergman

PA	PF	W/L	Date	Opponent	Location	Notes
18	20	L	09-16-1978	Rose-Hulman Tech (IN)	Terre Haute, IN
13	35	L	09-23-1978	Hope (MI)	Holland, MI
7	3	W	09-30-1978	Albion (MI)	Greencastle, IN
7	0	W	10-07-1978	Evansville (IN)	Greencastle, IN
0	31	L	10-14-1978	Valparaiso (IN)	Valparaiso, IN
0	26	L	10-21-1978	Indianapolis (IN)	Greencastle, IN
20	23	L	10-28-1978	Saint Joseph's (IN)	Rensselaer, IN
12	13	L	11-04-1978	Butler (IN)	Greencastle, IN
3	11	L	11-11-1978	Wabash (IN)	Crawfordsville, IN

1979 : 2-7-0

Coach: Jerry Berndt

PA	PF	W/L	Date	Opponent	Location	Notes
7	6	W	09-15-1979	Rose-Hulman Tech (IN)	Greencastle, IN
14	11	W	09-22-1979	Hope (MI)	Greencastle, IN
0	29	L	09-29-1979	Albion (MI)	Albion, MI
6	30	L	10-06-1979	Evansville (IN)	Evansville, IN
0	6	L	10-13-1979	Valparaiso (IN)	Greencastle, IN
0	21	L	10-20-1979	Olivet Nazarene (IL)	Bourbonnais, IL
10	28	L	10-27-1979	Saint Joseph's (IN)	Greencastle, IN
14	24	L	11-03-1979	Butler (IN)	Indianapolis, IN
13	16	L	11-10-1979	Wabash (IN)	Greencastle, IN